Friday, February 15, 2013

Lessons from Syria


Jade Salhab

There are two parts to this brilliant article by Beesaan el Shaikh in Al Hayat (Arabic) which I believe is an imperative read for anyone interested in the Arab uprising.

The first part of the article uses the tragedies generated by the revolution as a very compelling argument NOT to support it. The second part, near the end, turns the argument around making a simple but slam-dunk case for the revolution.

I want to use the first part to rephrase a position I expressed in the very beginning of this revolution, days before the first Assad speech and the subsequent violent turn of the uprising: I expressed then my hope that Assad would do the wise thing and grab the opportunity to reform the regime by himself, because that was the only transition that would avoid destroying Syria, or handing it to Islamic extremists.

I was naïve in my hopes, obviously. But I believe that hope is a moral imperative. I knew then, like all those who lived through Lebanon's civil war, that no matter where it happens on this earth, or why, or how legitimate, when an uprising turns into an armed rebellion, there is absolutely no controlling of the damage it can make to the structure of society and its ability to recuperate post conflict (think Iraq, Lebanon, but also Salvador, Tchetchnia, or Sri Lanka more globally).

The unspeakable price of civil violence in terms of social dismantling (even more so than the toll on human life and heritage), is why I still believe that any people who has regime change in progress (i.e Tunisia, Egypt) - or in perspective (i.e Jordan, Morocco, or the Gulf in the coming 5 to 15 years) - must bend itself backwards twice, maybe thrice, before engaging in violent struggle, or violent ‘defense of the achieved revolution’ – as opposed to radically peaceful rebellion or political compromise.

One of the reasons I respect Moaz el Khatib so deeply is his awareness of this fact, and his courage to remain constantly open to compromise with the regime for the sake of ending violence – because he knows that no matter how high the price of such compromise is, it will always be lower than the one of sustained violence.

Don’t get me wrong, just like Beesaan el Sheikh says in her article, I believe that there is no choice BUT to support the Syrian revolution because it is the only legitimate and humanly acceptable path forward. But I certainly hope that idealists learn the lesson and understand that wars are, under all circumstances, unwinnable: because even by winning them, we destroy the basic social infrastructure that makes that victory worth anything.

This might sound obvious to some, but the consequence is less so: only a slower transition, or a stubbornly peaceful uprising can come at a lower cost.

I want to end by drawing a relevance to Tunisia and Egypt: compromise is a high price you might need to pay to avoid the higher price of a torn society. And if compromise is impossible (and it should take a lot before you get to this conclusion), than maintain your struggle peaceful at all cost (i.e no military repression of ‘medieval forces’). The alternative is worse than you can ever imagine or calculate.

213 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 213 of 213
shemale escorts bangalore said...

High-Profile gurgaon Call Girls who will offer you veritable sweetheart experience. So call now- 8423121945.
call girls in gurgaon
gurgaon escorts
escorts in gurgaon

shemale escorts bangalore said...

Shimla Escorts are brilliant and they offer amazing Call Girls in shimla as Escorts in Bangalore deliver amazing bangalore Escorts Service to clients.Escorts services in shimla.
shimla escorts
escort services in shimla
escorts in shimla
call girls in shimla
call girl in shimla

shemale escorts bangalore said...

Call at 7022789089 for nehathakur hot and sexy bangalore Escorts girl offer Independent Cheap bangalore Escorts Service in bangalore and escorts service in near hotel zuri whitefield bangalore.
escorts service in near hotel zuri whitefield bangalore
call girls service near hotel zuri whitefield bangalore
near hotel zuri whitefield escorts service bangalore

shemale escorts bangalore said...

Available 24x7 hours escorts services in than 5 star hotels. Bangalore escorts will deliver you 100% genuine quality of service and escorts service in near shangri la hotel bangalore.
escorts service in near shangri la hotel bangalore
call girls service near shangri la hotel bangalore
shangri la hotel escorts service bangalore

priya said...

Have a nice blog
Thank for sharing Information
php online training in chennai
php programming center in chennai
php class in chennnai
php certification course
php developer training institution chennai
php training in chennnai
php mysql course in chennai
php institute in chennnai
php course in chennnai
php training with placement in chennnai
php developer course

priya said...

Great work!
NIce Blog
appium online training
appium training centres in chennai
best appium training institute in chennnai
apppium course
mobile appium in chennnai
mobile training in chennnai
appium training institute in chennnai

Mona Singh said...

Mona sharma are dating lover we have the best Noida escorts The Noida escort service is going through a wonderful time in its long service to the state. Noida escorts have been preferred above all other escorts in the northern part of India as the charm in lying with them on the bed feels out of the world. Noida escort service It is a great experience to bring home one of these women and most men have a good night’s rest after enjoying with the damsels in bed or on the sofa. Noida call girl have enjoyed the company of their customers and all in all it is a happy picture in the entire escort industry. Noida call girls women in the neighborhood now have a better lifestyle than what they had previously.

Independent Noida escorts state some reasons for the change in their lifestyle. delhi escorts One of the primary reasons for this change in the lifestyle is the expansion of the escort industry. Over the last few months delhi call girls has experienced a lot of cultural events that has shaped the neighborhood’s culture. Awareness programs talking about sexual maturity and development have been initiated frequently and it stands as no wonder that the people have undergone a vast change in their outlook. delhi escorts service They have understood about the measures to be taken to ensure that sex does not bring about a misfortune in their lives. delhi female escort message about the use of condoms and other preventive devices while having call girls in delhi sex has been propagated using loudspeakers and microphones. Noida has developed into an educated townMake your choices extend when you come to our agency for hiring a companion for your lusty desires. Because we have so many choices there to make your feelings sensual after seeing our Delhi Escort Girls.
gurgaon escorts
gurgaon escort service
gurgaon call girls
call girls in gurgaon.
ghaziabad escorts
ghaziabad call girl
call girls in ghaziabad
ghaziabad escort service
escorts ghaziabad
Faridabad escorts
Faridabad call girls
greater Noida escort service
escorts in greater Noida
call girl in greater Noida

riya4521 said...

Delhi has experienced the origin of housewives offering their services. Housewife Delhi escorts . I am riya here work as a high profile Call girl in delhi . I am here for last 6 years and have ability of fulfilling every sexual desires of every man. I am truly a self-independent and always ready to enjoy with you. refer to the women who have already been married and stay in the house to perform the household chores. Delhi escort service
housewives are cunning enough to keep their personal lives hidden under a veil of ignorance and innocence. Noida escorts for you night. then luckily you are landed on the right webpage. I am seema a hot sexy high demandingNoida escort service . my demand is the proof of my popularity among my clients. if you looking for call girl in Noida sexy killer queen I am perfect for you. I am professional in Noida call girls husbands believe that their wives have gone to give coaching to infants or children in school. Faridabad escorts This is pretty unfortunate as the truth is never revealed and the men are none the wiser.
gurgaon Call girls
gurgaon Escorts
gurgaon Escort service
call girls in gurgaon
Faridabad Call girls
Faridabad Escorts
Ghaziabad escort service
Ghaziabad escorts
Call girl in Ghaziabad
south Delhi call girls
call girls south Delhi
south Delhi Escorts
south Delhi escort service
noida city centre escorts
noida city centre escort service
call girls in noida city centre
call girls in noida sector 18
noida sector 18 escorts
noida sector 18 escort service
call girls in noida sector 12

riya4521 said...

Delhi has experienced the origin of housewives offering their services. Housewife Delhi escorts . I am riya here work as a high profile Call girl in delhi . I am here for last 6 years and have ability of fulfilling every sexual desires of every man. I am truly a self-independent and always ready to enjoy with you. refer to the women who have already been married and stay in the house to perform the household chores. Delhi escort service
housewives are cunning enough to keep their personal lives hidden under a veil of ignorance and innocence. Noida escorts for you night. then luckily you are landed on the right webpage. I am seema a hot sexy high demandingNoida escort service . my demand is the proof of my popularity among my clients. if you looking for call girl in Noida sexy killer queen I am perfect for you. I am professional in Noida call girls husbands believe that their wives have gone to give coaching to infants or children in school. Faridabad escorts This is pretty unfortunate as the truth is never revealed and the men are none the wiser.
gurgaon Call girls
gurgaon Escorts
gurgaon Escort service
call girls in gurgaon
Faridabad Call girls
Faridabad Escorts
Ghaziabad escort service
Ghaziabad escorts
Call girl in Ghaziabad
south Delhi call girls
call girls south Delhi
south Delhi Escorts
south Delhi escort service
noida city centre escorts
noida city centre escort service
call girls in noida city centre
call girls in noida sector 18
noida sector 18 escorts
noida sector 18 escort service
call girls in noida sector 12

Kenwood said...

I was impressed with the site that you created, so memotipasi many people to be more advanced, there also kunjugi me, as a comparison office 365

Cochin Passion said...

Cochin Escorts

Escorts in Cochin

Independent Escorts in Cochin

Cochin Escorts Models

Escorts Service in Cochin

Cochin Passion said...

Cochin Escorts

Escorts in Cochin

Independent Escorts in Cochin

Cochin Escorts Models

Escorts Service in Cochin

Mahi Chopra said...

Incall/Outcall Escorts Service in Mumbai at very reasonable prices. How much you can spend on a call girls its depends on you what kind of escorts service you want and what you want extra then escorts service through a call girls. When you select a girl for unlimited pleasure then you should know the quality of an independent mumbai escorts girls. Mahi Chopra will provide you high class escorts service within 30 mins. Just visit us or contact us for booking an escorts in mumbai.

Punjabi Call Girls in Mumbai | Mumbai Escort | Independent Mumbai Escorts | Independent Escorts in Mumbai | Mumbai Escorts Agency | Mumbai Escorts Service | Escorts Agency in Mumbai | Escorts Mumbai | Mumbai Female Escorts, Mumbai Escorts

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 213 of 213   Newer› Newest»